Are you familiar with this famous line: “Maybe she’s born with it, maybe it’s Maybelline.” Every makeup enthusiast might hear this tagline once; it is from one of the most popular makeup brands worldwide. Maybelline is the first brand budding makeup artists use because of its affordability.
I love how this makeup brand gives people the confidence to look and feel their best. Can you imagine how even a single makeup product can transform your face to a whole new level? For me, an eyeshadow palette is one of those things that is versatile in use—containing a wide range of colors can change your bare eyelids to a show-stopping eye makeup look.
More than anything, Maybelline’s eyeshadow palettes’ let you mix and match colors to your liking. Usually, the palette is of the same shade range or complementary to each other. Personally, when it comes to choosing an eyeshadow palette, I go for neutral colors; I always want a more natural look with a bit of freshness.
However, you can always go for bold and bright colors for a dramatic eye look. If you are feeling experimental, you can combine dark and light colors. Are you excited to see which Maybelline eyeshadow palette fits you best? Then keep on reading to find out.
Bottom Line Up Front
Out of all the Maybelline eyeshadow palettes, my favorite one would have to be the Nudes of New York 16 Pan Eyeshadow Palette. These gorgeous sixteen neutral shades are my ride or die for a daily, non-dramatic look.
With the Nudes of New York 16 Pan Eyeshadow Palette, you can mix and match them and still look amazing! You have some browns you can use as transition shades, some copper and yellow tone shimmers for that extra pop of color, and even purple shades when you are feeling dainty and want something out of the ordinary.
An even bigger bonus for this product is that there is `minimal fallout, so I would not worry about cleaning up any mess afterward.
My Top Picks Up Front
- The City Mini Eyeshadow Palette
- The 24K Nudes™ Eyeshadow Palette
- The Blushed Nudes® Eyeshadow Palette
- The Nudes Eyeshadow Palette
- Nudes of New York 16 Pan Eyeshadow Palette
- Total Temptation™ Eyeshadow + Highlight Palette
- The City Kits™ All-In-One Eye & Cheek Palette
- The Matte Bar Eyeshadow Makeup Palette
- Shadow Block Eyeshadow Makeup Palette
- Expert Wear® Eyeshadow
- Shadow Blocks Eyeshadow Palette
- Color Tattoo Up To 24Hr Longwear Cream Eyeshadow
Picking Out the Best of the Best
Let’s look at numerous factors to see which eyeshadow best fits you. Every single one of us has different product preferences. We are going to look at different formulations and sets of colors for each featured eyeshadow.
Picking the perfect eyeshadow takes time and research. In my preference, I like pigmented eyeshadow. Each ingredient or formula works differently for people. Some people like sheer eye makeup; however, I think chalky or sheer eyeshadow is a no-no. It’s also important to consider if it matches my skin well, making the color pop and not muddy.
Color Payoff and Application
Choose an eyeshadow palette with colors that has a range of hues, allowing for a muted or bold look. The best eyeshadow has an amazing color payoff— you get bright, deep pigment with just one swipe of the finger. If the color picks up from the pan to the brush or finger, it is definitely a good-quality eyeshadow.
And when it comes to application, a good eyeshadow offers versatility. You can apply your eyeshadow using a lot of methods. First is using a makeup brush of your choice—whether it be a flat one with a tapered end, a blending brush, or a flat shader brush.
Remember, some products are often chalky and powdery, leaving eyeshadow fallout. You can avoid this by tapping the brush before applying the shadows to your eyelids.
If you’re on the go, the best applicator is not a makeup brush! It’s your fingers. This is even my favorite method. I love using this, especially with glitter-based shades. This method picks up the most product, but the blending ability is a bit challenging.
Eyeshadow even has different types for you to enjoy. There are around four types with different consistencies and color payoff. Here is a small guide for you to differentiate them from each other:
Powder eyeshadows are the most common type available on the market. This type was the first one I tried as a budding makeup enthusiast. That’s why I believe it is the best type for a beginner makeup artist because it is the easiest to blend. Moreover, you can buy these pressed powder eyeshadows individually or in an eyeshadow palette.
Cream eyeshadow is the right choice for a bold and striking makeup look. I love the color intensity of this eyeshadow type. Furthermore, these are so pigmented and have no problem blending into the lids. Furthermore, these are available in pots, tubes, and stick formats.
Loose glitter eyeshadows are finely milled eyeshadows that are highly pigmented. The loose glitter is perfect for dramatic glam makeup looks. Moreover, this is my favorite eyeshadow type today because that is how extra I am as a person.
Like lip gloss, liquid eyeshadow comes in small, translucent tubes with an applicator wand. These are highly pigmented and hard to mess with since the formula is so creamy. Its consistency is less thick than that of a cream eyeshadow, though.
Researching a product does not stop here yet. Are the reviews mostly positive? What are they saying about the product? Do not forget to check out the comments people leave on the website. I love reading about the experiences of others when wearing eyeshadow.
Undoubtedly, I learn more about products than just sticking to the brand’s claims. You can check out reviews done by beauty influencers too! Through this, you can visualize how the eyeshadow looks on your eyelids.
How I Apply Eyeshadow
As always, I start with my skin prep, including my eyelids. I always make sure that my eyelids are ready to take on any makeup product. It’s also essential to cleanse and moisturize for a clean and smooth canvas.
Next is the base, which is an eyeshadow primer. For a more natural feel to my makeup, I skip this step. For an extra pop of color and long-lasting wear, I apply enough eyeshadow primer to prepare my eyelids—blend it using a brush or my fingers.
When everything is all set, start with a transition shade; this is usually a shade of neutral brown. Apply it to the crease and pick a darker color compared to my transition shade and put it at the corners of my eyes, blending it using the first shade I used.
Next, grab a shimmer or metallic shade and packed it on the center of my lids, working my way into a seamless finish. I then put on eyeliner, curled my lashes, put on fake lashes for that dramatic flare, and finished it with mascara.
How I Chose My Top Maybelline Eyeshadows
I first look at the colors to see how many shades I can use in the palette. It would be a waste to buy an eyeshadow palette with different colors that I could not frequently use before it expired.
Moreover, I will check its quality and authenticity. While Maybelline products are generally affordable, you might still find online stores on eBay, selling fake products. So, it’s always essential to purchase from authorized retailers and avoid overseas vendors.
Aside from checking the eyeshadow’s versatility and authenticity, I also pick the items on this list based on availability. You can buy them everywhere, be it in CVS, Walmart, or even at Target. It’s one of the best quality drugstore makeup brands.
You’ll also be spoilt for choice with dozens of options to choose from. I usually go for an eyeshadow palette with both matte and shimmer. I then check the reviews to see how it works for other buyers to see if it is worth the price. I swipe some colors on my hands or arm to see the color payoff when I buy something from a physical store.
My Favorite Maybelline Eyeshadows
Hold on to your seats! Here is my top list of the best Maybelline eyeshadows today.
The City Mini Eyeshadow Palette
I love this eyeshadow because the shades complement each other, and it’s one of the only palettes with an all-matte shade. There are six pans inside, so there are endless creative makeup looks that are achievable. The pigments are great because they do not fade away when applied to the skin.
The pigments in the palette are soft and blendable with each other. Also, its price point is acceptable, and it comes in a small compact that you can take anywhere for touch-ups.
One downside that I found with this one is the fallout. You have to be very careful when packing it on your lids. My advice: apply a primer first, then put on the colors using a dense brush. Another suggestion is to do your eye makeup before your face, so you do not have to redo it.
- Perfect everyday palette with one base color on the top left, two crease colors on the bottom left pans, two lid colors on the top right pans, and one liner color on the bottom right pan.
- Blendable and Creamy Texture
- A lot of fallout
- Small packaging
- No applicator
The 24K Nudes™ Eyeshadow Palette
I also love the color combination of this palette. It has both everyday tones and bold colors to match any of your makeup looks. It is easy to apply, and I obsess over the brown shades at the top of the palette. Moreover, the shimmer shades are to die for; they are adorable and glide easily on the lids.
The dazzling combination of metallics and shimmering nudes creates an extremely versatile look. While the colors look pigmented right off the bat, some colors, especially the green and purples, do not My advice is to wet your brush first and to apply a bit of pressure when using the colors.
- Works best on top of an eyeshadow primer
- 12 shades in one palette
- Too dry formula
- Needs damp-brush application
- Blotchy and Patchy finish when used without eyeshadow primer
The Blushed Nudes® Eyeshadow Palette
The packaging of the Blushed Nudes palette is so cute! It is pink and has a clear, transparent lid where you can see the beautiful shades. Another great thing is that when you look at the back, Maybelline has a guide for quads, trios, or duo looks with the respective shades for easy navigation. I love how the company makes it easier, especially for those who are still starting to learn makeup.
A stumbling block I encountered with this is its pigmentation. However, the shades were still workable, and you can apply a primer first to make the colors stick better. But the eyeshadows with shimmers are great.
- No strong scent
- Suits both warm and cool skin tones
- Cute and Sturdy Packaging
- Easy to build and apply
- Chalky formula
- Not Long-Lasting
- Some colors don’t come out of the pan
The Nudes Eyeshadow Palette
I like how the shades are great for everyday and glam looks. It is a perfect mixture of mattes, shimmers, and satin shades. Moreover, I get sweaty, but this eyeshadow stays on my face even after a few hours. My one comment is that the formula could have been great. The shimmer ones are stunning, but I have a bit of trouble figuring out how to avoid fallout. To be frank, it could have been more pigmented.
- Neat and Lightweight packaging
- Pigmented and Buildable
- Great Everyday Wear
- Not really a show-stopper product
- Severe fallout
- Quite Chalky and Dusty
Nudes of New York 16 Pan Eyeshadow Palette
This eyeshadow is perfect if you are looking for highly pigmented, beautiful shades of neutrals and shimmer. You can create a lot of different makeup looks with just one small palette. It comes with sixteen shades, making the price very reasonable. I also love the shimmer, and it is more like a metallic formula, so it goes smoothly on my eyelids.
However, one downside is that I wish there were more wide shades. Some are nearly identical to each other, like the matte shades.
- Highly-pigmented and beautiful shade combo
- Extremely easy to apply and blend
- Perfect for Neutral Glam Looks
- Nicer, if there are other shades
- Low color payoff on crease colors
- Colors are not as rich as they appear
Total Temptation™ Eyeshadow + Highlight Palette
I like this idea of hitting two birds with one stone in makeup. You can have eyeshadow and a highlighter in just one palette—how cool is that? The color payoff is the same on the pan and on the eyes. Also, the package looks luxurious, which I love.
One disadvantage to this eyeshadow is that it can be hard to blend. I tried wet and dry brushes and my fingers, but it was a struggle. It is a bit of a letdown if you ask me because I was so hyped about the idea of a highlighter and eyeshadow in one container.
- Has both cool-toned and warm-toned shades
- It gives a nice luminosity to the skin
- Best for individuals with fair complexion
- Some shades have glitter top coats, but not much reflects upon the application
- Eyeshadows easily crack
- Powdery Formula
The City Kits™ All-In-One Eye & Cheek Palette
This eyeshadow can become a holy grail for those just starting with makeup. Like the Total Temptation palette, this one comes with another product besides eyeshadow. It has a cheek palette and eyeshadow in one product. The shadows go well together on the lids and are very easy to blend.
However, for me, it was just an okay product. Also, I encountered a packaging issue where a shade in the palette broke, which I barely tapped.
- Generous pans with a variety of shades plus the blush and highlighter
- Great beginner palette
- Soft and Subtle Colors
- The packaging looks like a toy makeup
- Flimsy case, some pans broke even without dropping the product
- Not great for darker complexion
The Matte Bar Eyeshadow Makeup Palette
The quality of this eyeshadow is great. The color easily shows with little fallout. I love all the ten matte shades and their sizes in this palette. Moreover, it is very versatile if you want a day or evening look. Despite its positive points, I would like to point out that I had difficulty blending it into my lids. It came out patchy, and I had to use a sponge just to achieve the pigmentation I wanted.
- Minimal creasing
- Buildable soft shades
- Chic and sleek packaging
- Hard to blend
- Colors look watered down
- Fades in a few hours; reapplication is necessary
Expert Wear® Eyeshadow
If you are into the natural eye makeup look, you will be sold on this product. It gives off a natural feel but enough pigment for that nice pop of color in the eyes. This product comes in a single shade, so choose a shade that you see yourself wearing every day.
Moreover, it comes with a small eye applicator sponge that can help pack the colors into the lids. The good news is that the formula is so creamy and applies nicely.
In contrast, I have some comments about some of the shades in the Expert Wear eyeshadow. Especially with the yellow shade, it comes off as chunky, and the color payoff is not consistent. Although it is understandable because of the formulation, it became a bit of a letdown for me.
- Velvety texture and super-saturated colors
- Highly pigmented in one swipe
- Long-wearing, perfect for special occasions
- Inconsistent formula compared to other shades
- Not great for travels since there’s only one shade per product
- Some of the best shades (Earthly Taupe, NY Silver) are discontinued
Shadow Blocks Eyeshadow Palette
The packaging for this product is so cool! It is three-stacked and pocket-size, which does not take up a lot of space in my makeup stash. It contains two matte shades and one shimmer, which are all easy to use, and the color payoffs are just exquisite.
By comparison to its pros, it tends to crease on the lids. I recommend putting a primer first to lessen the creasing.
- The formula is nice and smooth
- Creative and unique packaging
- Perfect for a natural everyday look
- The colors are great but not long-lasting
- Not travel-friendly with such a bulky case
- Quite drying on the eyes
Color Tattoo Up To 24Hr Longwear Cream Eyeshadow
This is one of the cream eyeshadows on my list. Like the Expert Wear eyeshadow, it also has one shade or color and not an entire palette. While you can make a bold make-up look with just one shade, it gives off an incredibly easy application, either with your finger or a brush.
It has a shimmery finish with just enough color on the lids. Besides that, it has a matte finish, so there is no need to worry about creasing. Nevertheless, this eyeshadow is not for a workday look. Some are too shimmery or too matte to mix and match. In addition, some shades do not match the color they claim online, so checking out reviews is a must.
- Lasts all day long
- Smudge-proof and Transfer-proof
- Goes on easy and stays put
- Dries out quickly
- Too much fallout; quite messy
- Limited color options
Best Maybelline Eye Shadow : FAQs
Question: Is Maybelline cruelty-free?
Answer: According to their website, Maybelline and its parent company, L’Oreal, no longer tests their products on animals anywhere in the world. However, some regulatory boards may demand to have their products tested on animals. This means that Maybelline might not be 100% cruelty-free.
Question: Is Maybelline vegan?
Answer: The short answer is NO! Some Maybelline products might be vegan-friendly, but you still have to be careful. Always check the label and ingredients. You shouldn’t purchase any makeup products with carmine and lanolin.
Question: Which Maybelline eyeshadow is waterproof?
Answer: It’s the Color Tattoo Cream Eyeshadow. There are quite a few long-lasting and smudge-proof eyeshadow products from Maybelline, but the Color Tattoo Cream Eyeshadow pots are definitely impressive with a super-saturated color payoff lasting for 24-hour tattoo intensity. It has a waterproof formula, minimizing fading and creasing all day long.
Question: What’s the best travel-friendly Maybelline eyeshadow?
Answer: I find the City Mini Eyeshadow Palette the perfect travel eyeshadow. With six shades in a palette, you get to play around and create endless makeup looks. Its packaging is also great since you can simply throw it inside your suitcase with zero hassle and worries.
Question: Is Maybelline a good eyeshadow brand overall?
Answer: When it comes to good-quality drugstore makeups, Maybelline doesn’t disappoint. It’s been a staple for many makeup enthusiasts and has offered new and exciting ways to spruce up your eye look. I swear by Maybelline as an affordable, no-non-sense brand you can rely on.
Nudes of New York 16 Pan Eyeshadow Palette: My Go-to Eyeshadow Palette
Maybelline is hands-down, by far, one of the best makeup brands out there on the market. They have a lot of different eyeshadows, perfect for every skin tone and skin complexion. My personal favorite would always be the Nudes of New York 16 Pan Eyeshadow Palette. I do not need to buy other products with this product since it contains all the colors I need.
Eyeshadows can make or break your overall look. It brings dimension and attention to your eyes and completes your makeup. They make you more attractive than you already are by enhancing your existing features. I hope you choose your product wisely, and I hope these tips I gave can help you.
• Maybelline Color Tattoo Review
- Best Chanel Foundation Options: You Need to Try #3 - September 10, 2022
- Best Gold Lipsticks Guide: How I’d Recommend You Style This Bold Lip Color - August 26, 2022
- Best Maybelline Eye Shadow To Try - July 21, 2022