Best NYX Lip Liner
| | | |

Best NYX Lip Liner Ideas: How To Wear Your Favorite Shades

There’s one makeup trend that’s made a grand resurgence lately, and I am here for it. Of course, I’m talking about lip liner. From subtle lip contouring to dramatic, shadowed pouts, lip liner is getting a glow up and it’s about time you took notice!

I’ll fully admit that I’ve only been using lip liner for a couple of years now, as it always seemed like one extra, unnecessary step in my routine. And let’s be honest, it’s not an everyday necessity, but rather a tool for enhancing an already amazing look. So if you’re new to the lip liner game, or maybe just looking to dabble in some new products, this is a great place to start.

Let NYX be your one-stop shop for all your liner needs because this brand has every color under the rainbow, multiple different formulas, and amazing prices. From the cult-classic Slim Lip Pencil to the Suede Matte Lip Liner, there’s a product for any type of look you’re trying to create.

An Overview of Your Options

Slim Lip Pencil 

The Slim Lip Pencil is arguably the most “classic” lip liner NYX has to offer, with a natural finish and smooth formula that’s meant to blend easily while preventing your other pip products from bleeding. For beginners, this is a great place to start as you can move and manipulate this buttery product easily. The thin shape of the pencil also allows for effortless precision, something we could all use a little help with!


Slim, trim, but never prim our lip pencils come in a variety of dashing shades - from auburn to orange and traffic-stopping red. The buttery long-wearing lip liner formula goes on easily and resists bleeding.

Buy at Amazon Buy at NYX
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
01/21/2024 10:26 am GMT

Suede Matte Lip Liner

Take the Slim Lip Pencil, add a powdery matte finish and chunkier tip and you’ve got the Suede Matte Lip Liner. Designed specifically to complement matte lipsticks, this formula will give you a great base for your favorite lip toppers and lipsticks. It’s also got great stay-power, so you can rest assured that this liner won’t budge throughout the day.

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Suede Matte Lip Liner | Amazon

Buh-bye creamy lip colors! See ya shimmery shades! A velvety, Matte lip is an absolute must and we've got just the goodie to help you get it done right: Suede Matte Lip Liner.

Buy at Amazon Buy at NYX
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
01/21/2024 10:36 am GMT

Retractable Lip Liner 

nyx retractable lip liner

As the name suggests, this liner is an easy-to-use, twist-up product that won’t require sharpening. It’s a more creamy formula than the previous two products, with rich pigment that makes it great for everyday use. You can even smudge this one all over your lips for a stain-like effect!


Love your lips! Create the perfect pout with our creamy, richly pigmented liner in an easy twist-up pencil. Renowned for its staying power! Available in 15 irresistible shades.

Check Price Buy at Ulta
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Slide On Lip Pencil 

Slide On Lip Pencil

If you’re the type to always grab the waterproof versions of your favorite products, this one is for you. This liner is highly pigmented and waterproof, with a velvety matte finish, meaning it’s staying on your lips all day long. If you want extra assurance that your makeup will stay put, this is a great option.

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Slide On Lip Pencil, Lip Liner | Amazon

Pucker up and apply the Slide On Lip Pencil for rich, matte color. Like our award-winning eyeliner, this waterproof pencil goes on extra smooth with a long-wearing finish.

Buy at Amazon Buy at Ulta
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
01/21/2024 10:52 am GMT

Shape Loud Matte Lip Duo 

Shape Loud Matte Lip Duo

NYX has made your life so much simpler with this two-in-one product. You’ll find a different shade of lip pencil on either end, which makes it a versatile product you’ll get plenty of use out of. Use each shade individually as a liner, or together for a beautiful matte look. Use one color to line your lips and the other to blend into your lips for an ombré effect!

Shape Loud Matte Lip Duo | NYX

Shape your lips with dual-ended creamy matte shades made for all skin tones. Inspired by legendary makeup professionals, this new limited edition blendable formula is a 2-step process to ombré perfection.

Check Price
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Dazed and Diffused Blurring Lip Liner 

Here’s another multi-use product that’s made with the busy gal in mind. It’s a dual-ended product that features a creamy lip liner infused with jojoba oil on one end and a synthetic lip brush on the other. You can use the brush to create a soft, diffused look or even an ombre effect!

$18.49 ($18.49 / Count)

Dual-Ended Lip Liner Description How to apply Ingredients Line, fill & perfect your pout with our Dazed & Diffused Blurring Lip Liner. This dual-ended lip liner features a jojoba oil infused jumbo pencil to smoothly line, define, and fill your lips with rich, velvety-matte color.

Buy at Amazon Buy at NYX
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
01/21/2024 11:06 am GMT

Which One Is Right For You?

With all these options, it might be difficult to determine which NYX lip liner is the best fit for you. So here are my suggestions.

If this is your first time playing with lip liner, definitely go with the classic Slim Lip Pencil. It’s easy to apply and clean up (for those inevitable errors), and it comes in 39 shades, meaning you’re sure to find one that suits your color preference and skin tone. Start with a couple of nude shades and practice contouring around your lips!

Now, let’s say you’re looking for something equally versatile and easy to use, but you prefer bold colors and a matte finish. Your best bet is going to be the Suede Matte Lip Liner. With nearly 80 color options, from blue to orange, you’re sure to find some shades that suit you. And for those nights when you want a bold pop of color, this liner will keep your lipstick locked into place for hours on end.

Similarly, the Slide on Lip Pencil is great for those who prefer bold colors and a highly pigmented lip look. I’d suggest picking this product up if you’re prone to lipstick smudging or running, or if you’re planning on a long night of eating and drinking, because of its amazing waterproof stay-power. And if you’re a fan of getting caught in the rain, this is the liner for you.

Next, I’ve got the perfect option for the busy gal on the go…or for the lazy makeup lovers out there (ahem, me). The NYX Retractable Lip Liner is a great product to have in your everyday makeup bag and your purse for on-the-go touchups.

Unlike the Sim Lip Pencil and Suede Matte Lip Liner, you won’t need a sharpener for this product, which is a great way to simplify your routine. Just twist the pencil for a fresh tip every time! It only comes in 15 shades, but they’re extremely versatile and complementary to a variety of lip colors.

For the makeup enthusiasts and adventurous types, you might move away from these classic products and try something unique. One of my favorites is the Dazed and Diffused Blurring Lip Liner.

It’s a product unlike any other I’d seen before and makes it super easy to create a variety of looks with just one tool. Play around with soft, blurred liner looks, create an ombré effect by layering and smudging the product, or apply it all over for a pigmented, one-and-done lip stain look.

And finally, if you want to try something new, but are not a fan of the diffused, blurred look, try out the Shape Loud Matte Lip Duo, an easy-to-use product that comes with two complementary colors for contouring and layering. You can effortlessly create multiple lips looks with just one of these pencils, which come in four fun shades, from nude brown to bright pink.

My Experience

Out of NYX’s six lip liners, I identified three to be my favorite. That’s certainly not to say you need all three of these liners in your collection, but I find that each has a slightly different use and can help supplement all the different lip looks I might want to create.

So here are my top three favorites and a few takeaways for each.

Slim Lip Pencil

  • Excellent shade range
  • Creamy, smooth formula
  • Easy to apply and sharpen
  • Stays put for several hours
  • Buildable color for both soft and bold looks
  • Best for everyday use

Retractable Lip Liner

  • Creamiest formula
  • Rich, pigmented color
  • Easy to use with no sharpener needed
  • Fine tip for precision
  • Easy to adjust and fix errors
  • Best for ultra-pigmented lip stains and lipsticks

Dazed and Diffused Blurring Lip Liner

  • Unique, fun product
  • Great for creating diffused, blurred liner looks
  • Good for fun, ombré looks and buildable color
  • Good for beginners
  • Multi-use and long-lasting

Best Lip Product Pairings

Lip liner certainly can be used by itself and many of these NYX products can be applied all over your pout for a stain-like effect, but ultimately liners do tend to work best when paired with another lip topper. Whether you prefer lipsticks, lip stains, liquid lip products, or lip gloss, you can pair your favorite products with nearly any of these NYX liners.

However, I’ve identified a few great combinations to make your life simple!


Best NYX Lip Liner Ideas

If you’re the traditional type that loves a good, creamy lipstick, I recommend pairing the Slim Lip Pencil or Retractable Lip Liner with NYX’s Shout Loud Satin Lipstick, Filler Instinct Plumping Lip Color, or Extra Creamy Round Lipstick.

The Shout Loud Satin Lipstick is packed with intense color and a semi-matte finish, which the Extra Creamy Round Lipstick has an extra dose of hydration for a creamier, velvety effect. If you prefer a more sheer finish, go for the Filler Instinct Plumping Lip Color which will work best with the Slim Lip Pencil.

Lip Stains & Liquid Lipsticks

I am personally a big fan of lip stains and liquid lipsticks for their ability to last hours and hours, and the intense color you often get from them. One of my favorites is the NYX Soft Matte Lip Cream, which is perfectly paired with the Suede Matte Lip Liner.

I also adore the Powder Puff Lippie Lip Cream, which is meant to give a powdery, soft finish to the lips. That one is best paired with the Dazed and Diffused Blurring Lip Liner for an ultra-soft look. And if you want something that will stay on your lips through a swim in the ocean, several rounds of cocktails, and a long makeout sesh, pair the Slide On Lip Pencil with the NYX Lip Lingerie XXL Matte Liquid Lipstick, which promises a whopping 16 hours of wear.

Lip Glosses

The Shape Loud Matte Lip Duo is a great product to use with your favorite lip gloss or sparkly topper since it’s already a two-in-one product that can be used just as a liner or as all-over color.

The cult classic Butter Gloss will deliver a non-sticky formula and sheer color that will complement but not detract from the pigmented Lip Duo. For something that’s equally as hydrating as it is shiny, try the Milky Gloss, which is packed with vegan milk for soft, hydrated lips.

Shape Loud Matte Lip Duo | NYX

Shape your lips with dual-ended creamy matte shades made for all skin tones. Inspired by legendary makeup professionals, this new limited edition blendable formula is a 2-step process to ombré perfection.

Check Price
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.


Question: Are NYX Lip Liners creamy?

Answer: If a creamy lip liner is what you’re looking for, you can find one from NYX. The creamiest liners are going to be the Slim Lip Pencil and Retractable Lip Liner, though all of the NYX liners lean toward the creamy, smooth side.

Question: How much is NYX lip pencil?

Answer: NYX lip liners range from $4 to $10, with the cheapest options being the Slim Lip Pencil and Suede Matte Lip Liner.

Question: Is NYX Slide On Lip Liner Retractable?

Answer: The Slide On Lip Liner is not retractable and will require a sharpener. The only retractable liner option from NYX is the Retractable Lip Liner.

Question: How do I use NYX Lip Liner?

Answer: Like all lip liners, the way you use your NYX products is totally up to you. Some people prefer to match their liners to their all-over lip color for a smooth effect, while some like the contouring effect of a deeper liner color. In general, though, all of the NYX liners are meant to enhance your pout by applying a natural outline of the lips and creating a barrier that prevents smudging or bleeding of your lip color.

Question: How do you sharpen a NYX lip pencil?

Answer: You can use any sharpener that has a small opening for the non-retractable lip liners. NYX does also sell their Professional Makeup Sharpener, which can be used with a number of their products.

Best Nyx Lip Liner Ideas: Conclusion

Anyone who is a fan of the NYX brand knows there’s no shortage of products to choose from, with options for every skin tone, skin type, makeup look, and color preference. With six lip liners to choose from, you can easily find a formula that works best for your desired look. Pick up two or three different types and play around with creating a bold, bright lip, soft powdery pout, or classic glossy look!

Read More: NYX Nude Truffle Lip Liner Review & Guide Lip Liner Hype

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *