Best Hypoallergenic Eyeliner Options For Sensitive Eyes

I love to enhance the natural beauty of my brown eyes with black eyeliner. I believe it gives me that sophisticated appearance and makes me walk out the door and face the world with more confidence. Eyeliner makeup, if done correctly, will draw attention to the eye area while also improving the shape of your eyes.

However, some of us deal with sensitive skin, especially around the eyes; for that reason, if you’re one of those people but you don’t want to give up on using eyeliner, you should look for a product that has hypoallergenic ingredients. Eyeliners that contain chemicals could lead to itching, swelling, irritations, and other allergic reactions.

Because I want to help you overcome this struggle, I have listed and detailed some of the best hypoallergenic eyeliner options that you can find on the market.

Best Hypoallergenic Eyeliner Options – Top 8 Choices

The following makeup products were listed in no specific order. I have chosen them based on their customer reviews, ingredients, and hypoallergenic features.

1. Eye Booster Eyeliner and Serum

The Eye Booster eyeliner made by Physician’s Formula, Inc. is a hypoallergenic beauty product that’s also very pigmented. With this eyeliner pen, you will be able to create numerous dramatic eye looks, almost effortlessly. It’s a waterproof eyeliner that’s resistant to smudges and, once applied, will last for a long time on your eyelids.

The pen features a special tip that enables easy application. The formula is rich and boosts the length, thickness, and volume of your eyelashes. This is a 2-in-1 product that serves a double purpose: it’s an eyeliner and an eyelash serum.

Pros

  • You can wear it the entire day because it’s very resistant;
  • This eyeliner is fragrance-free and it doesn’t contain parabens;
  • Many dermatologists have approved the use of this hypoallergenic makeup product.

Cons

  • It’s waterproof. Therefore, removing it might be a little tricky.

Eye Booster Eyeliner and Serum | Amazon

Eye Booster 2-in-1 lash boosting eyeliner + serum deep brown.

Check Price
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

2. Precision Liquid Eyeliner by Neutrogena

Precision Liquid Eyeliner by Neutrogena

I must confess that I love this liquid eyeliner despite the fact that I don’t have the necessary skills to use it. That’s why I prefer using eyeliners that can be applied with a stick or a pencil instead of a brush. This Neutrogena eyeliner contains coconut and honey and it’s a great option for those who have sensitive skin.

It is a resistant product that won’t fade away with just water. It’s also very pigmented. Most of those who have used this eyeliner praise it to be a mess-free and enjoyable experience. Plus, with every new stroke and application, you will improve your makeup skills and you’ll become better at applying liquid eyeliner.

Pros

  • This product is easy to use;
  • The formula is suitable for those who have sensitivity issues;
  • It dries up quickly;
  • You will be able to create sharp and clean lines with it;
  • It stays on without smudging, all day long;
  • This liquid eyeliner glides smoothly on your eyelids;
  • The tip of the applicator is pointed to boost precision.

Cons

  • A few clients have complained about the fact that they’ve noticed smudges after wearing this eyeliner for hours at a time.

Precision Liquid Eyeliner by Neutrogena | Amazon
$17.96

Water-resistant, liquid eyeliner that allows for precise application. Formulated with Honey and Coconut, designed to resist smudging. Hypoallergenic.

Buy at Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
12/07/2022 05:26 am GMT

3. Definition Waterproof Eyeliner by KIKO Milano

Definition Waterproof Eyeliner by KIKO Milano

KIKO Milano eyeliner is an amazing product since it’s hypoallergenic and very easy to apply. The formula and its definition are safe and gentle. This eyeliner comes with a highly precise brush applicator with a thin tip that allows a mess-free experience. It’s a water-based formula that features a creamy texture which makes it easier for you to create any kind of line and shape you desire.

Your eyes will be embellished by beautiful black lines that have a slight touch of sheer. This highly pigmented waterproof eyeliner will help you achieve a cat-eye appearance or a more subtle look without giving you any allergic reactions.

Pros

  • The consistency is creamy and glides smoothly on your eyelids;
  • The formula is hypoallergenic and contains non-comedogenic ingredients;
  • It was tested and approved by various ophthalmologists;
  • This product has a water-based formula that’s very lightweight on your skin.

Cons

  • It doesn’t dry up as quickly as you might expect. So, you must be careful not to smudge it.

Definition Waterproof Eyeliner by KIKO Milano | Amazon
£7.89 (£175.33 / 100 ml)

Easy to use waterproof Liquid Eyeliner with a fine brush applicator.

Buy at Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
12/07/2022 07:11 am GMT

4. Shimarz AbsoluteBlack Eyeliner

Shimarz AbsoluteBlack Eyeliner

What makes this eyeliner a special one, besides being hypoallergenic, is its vegan formula that’s made only with natural ingredients. This Shimarz Absolute Black eyeliner has many nourishing substances that are very gentle on your eyes. It will provide you with dramatic and sexy eye makeup without causing skin rashes or irritations.

The consistency of this eyeliner is smooth and creamy and it will glide easily on your eyelids. You can achieve a fabulous look in just a couple of strokes. It’s a lightweight eyeliner but it’s also resistant. The creamy texture allows you to blend it nicely to create the popular smokey eye look.

Pros

  • It’s easy to apply;
  • This is a long-lasting eyeliner;
  • It doesn’t contain any harsh chemicals;
  • It’s a vegan and cruelty-free product;
  • The eyeliner blends smoothly and easily.

Cons

  • Some of you might find it a bit hard to apply this product because of its design but I love it since it comes in a pencil form which makes it so much easier to apply it without fearing that the lines won’t be straight.

Shimarz Black Eyeliner Pencil | Amazon
$14.99

Save 10 minutes every day by gliding on your desired eye look without pain or tugging of your eyelids.

Buy at Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
12/07/2022 10:51 am GMT

5. Legit Pencil Eyeliner by Youngblood

youngblood legit pencil eyeliner

Youngblood Legit eyeliner is infused with natural ingredients which makes this makeup product a great choice for those who have sensitive skin. It’s a pretty versatile pencil due to the fact that you can also use it as kohl. If you want to create smokey eyes, all you have to do is apply a bit of this product and then blend it on your skin by using a blending brush.

The color of this eyeliner is pigmented and rich. This eye makeup item contains both marula oil and vitamin E which are two nourishing compounds. You can choose between one shade of black and two shades of brown.

Pros

  • It is a long-lasting hypoallergenic eyeliner;
  • Its size and design makes it a travel-friendly product;
  • The formula is nourishing and hydrating;
  • It is free from chemicals and non-natural ingredients.

Cons

  • It might not be as long-lasting as expected.

Legit Pencil Eyeliner by Youngblood | Amazon
£11.00 (£964.91 / 100 g)

The rich, long-lasting color won't tug or irritate. Sharpens to a fine point for complete precision, or smudges for a sultry, smoky look.

Buy at Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
12/07/2022 02:05 pm GMT

6. Baeblu Eyeliner

Baeblu Eyeliner

This Baeblu hypoallergenic eyeliner is formulated with natural ingredients that are mild on the skin. In fact, this product is the perfect mix of deep-seated pigments and non-toxic ingredients. It’s a gluten-free formula that comes in the form of a pencil. There are three different available shades that you can choose from black, brown, and smoke.

According to the manufacturer, this eyeliner is resistant to sweat and smudges due to the fact that the formula includes castor oil and jojoba oil. These ingredients will make the product glide effortlessly on your eyelids while also hydrating and nourishing your skin. All it takes for beautiful eye makeup are a couple of strokes and then you’re done.

Pros

  • It is a fragrance-free eyeliner;
  • This eyeliner contains natural pigments and it is toxin-free;
  • You can wear it all day long because it is resistant to sweat;
  • It is a cruelty-free product since it’s not tested on animals.

Cons

  • Perfection does not exist so expect this eyeliner to smudge a little, once in a while, after you’ve worn it for many hours at a time.

BaeBlu Natural Hypoallergenic Eyeliner Pencil | Amazon
$14.19

Our pencils are very long-lasting. Our mineral makeup blend gives our pencils a rich, ultra-deep color that looks just like many of the other pencils you may have used, but without the toxins.

Buy at Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
12/07/2022 09:01 am GMT

7. Marcelle Waterproof Eyeliner

Marcelle Waterproof Eyeliner

This is an amazing hypoallergenic kohl eyeliner that’s marketed by the brand Marcelle. Its formula is lovely, being long-lasting, creamy, and rich. The tip of the eye pencil ensures very precise strokes. With this product, you can create numerous eye looks such as soft and dreamy wings, more dramatic smokey eyes, etc.

This Marcelle hypoallergenic eyeliner is clean and safe and it doesn’t have fragrance. According to the company, the product is tested and approved by dermatologists. You can use this eyeliner even if you wear contact lenses. The thing I love most is the wide range of amazing shades: midnight black, blue lagoon, electric blue, emerald, expresso, purple rain, and more.

Pros

  • It’s a fragrance-free and cruelty-free product;
  • It doesn’t contain alcohol and it’s gentle on your skin;
  • This eyeliner is long-lasting and waterproof;
  • Dermatologists have tested and approved it.

Cons

  • You might feel the need for touch-ups in order to reapply this eyeliner from time to time. 

Marcelle Waterproof Eyeliner | Amazon
$13.94

Tears, heat, and humidity don’t stand a chance with this long-lasting waterproof eyeliner; This creamy, easy-to-use formula allows for precise lines or a more smudged finish.

Buy at Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
12/07/2022 09:41 am GMT

8. Revitalash Defining Liner

Revitalash Defining Liner

I simply love this eyeliner which is why I’ve decided to talk about it last. It leaves you with a nice silky sensation and it’s super gentle and nourishing. The Revitalash eyeliner is pigmented and full of silicone emollients that have the role of locking in the proper level of skin hydration. Your skin will remain soft and supple due to this product’s content of vitamin E.

It’s a creamy formula that’s very easy to apply. Being hypoallergenic makes this product a safe choice that could prevent skin irritations. I am sure that you will consider the built-in sharpener a very useful tool that comes in handy on many occasions. This eyeliner is available in two different colors: black and slate.

Pros

  • This eyeliner is free from oil;
  • It has a nice creamy texture;
  • It comes with a very useful built-in sharpener;
  • The Revitalash eyeliner is a cruelty-free and vegan makeup product;
  • It doesn’t contain parabens, added fragrances, and phthalates;
  • It also has a smudging tool.

Cons

  • Some of you might not consider this eyeliner pigmented enough.

RevitaLash Defining Eyeliner | Amazon

A richly pigmented, easy-to-use, cream eyeliner formula for high-impact, stay-true color.

Buy at Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Choosing the Best Hypoallergenic Eyeliner that You Can Afford

Now, it is time to talk about the things you should consider before buying hypoallergenic eyeliner. There are three main aspects you need to think about: ingredients, formula, and avoiding harmful chemicals. Below, I will also show you how you can verify if you’re allergic or not to regular eyeliners, even when you haven’t tried them yet.

Things to Consider

Formula

eyeliner for sensitive eyes

It is always wise to opt for an eyeliner that features a lightweight formula, especially if you have sensitive skin and want to use a hypoallergenic product. Natural eyeliners with a heavy pigment could also be a suitable choice because they hydrate your eyelids and prevent your eyes from becoming dry;

Ingredients

I always read the label before I purchase any product, especially when it comes to food and cosmetics. The list of ingredients will tell you a lot about that specific item.

The best kinds of eyeliners are those that are formulated with natural ingredients. Vegan and plant-based eyeliners should definitely be on your go-to list as well as those that don’t contain artificial compounds. Look for ingredients such as castor oil, vitamin E, and jojoba oil, all of which will nourish your eye skin;

Harsh chemicals

When reading the ingredient list, make sure that the eyeliner you’re about to buy doesn’t contain allergenic and harmful chemicals. Avoid those products that contain carbon, mineral oil, parabens, sulfates, formaldehyde, and phthalates.

The Proper Way to See If You’re Allergic or Not to Eyeliner

If, after you’ve used an eyeliner, you’re experiencing the following symptoms, it might mean that you’re allergic to that product and should consider changing it with a hypoallergenic alternative:

  • Redness;
  • Tears;
  • Dry patches;
  • Skin irritations;
  • Itching.

It’s important to pay attention to your skin and the way your body reacts after using a cosmetic or makeup product. There are numerous options on the market and it’s hard to choose one. But, keep in mind that not all those products are safe and suitable for your skin type. And, if you’re allergic to eyeliner, don’t be scared about it. You’re not alone; there are literally hundreds of people out there who have experienced eyeliner-related allergies, at least once in their lifetime.

For that reason, you should invest in a high-quality hypoallergenic eyeliner, regardless of whether your skin is sensitive or not. Your skin will thank you!

FAQs

Question: How Long Can You Keep the Eyeliner for Before Throwing It Out?

Answer: Every makeup and the cosmetic product has its own expiration date that you should consider when using it. So, make sure to check that date before buying an eyeliner and keep it until it expires, as written on the label.

Question: What Are the Elements that Are Known to Cause Allergic Reactions?

Answer: In general, the most common allergens are found in foods, preservatives, pollens, complex substances, and fragrances. When it comes to eyeliners, you should avoid those products that contain chemicals such as parabens and sulfates. Instead, opt for a product that’s natural and fragrance-free.

Question: What Are the Most Common Signs of a Skin Allergic Reaction?

Answer: Here are some of the signs that could tell you there’s something wrong with your body and you’re probably experiencing an allergic reaction:
• Itchy skin;
• Rashes;
• Wheezing;
• Peeling skin;
• Irritated eyes, mouth, and nose;
• Facial swelling; etc

Best Hypoallergenic Eyeliner Options – Bottom Line

If you’re having trouble finding the right eyeliner for your skin type, I hope that today’s article has helped you make a decision. Hypoallergenic eyeliners made of natural ingredients are always a great choice for everyone, regardless of their skin type and skin sensitivity. Remember to read the ingredient list before purchasing this product.

When it comes to brands, there are many options on the market that I am sure will satisfy your needs, requirements, and preferences. My personal favorite one is the Revitalash defining liner due to its creamy and oil-free texture. I also love the fact that it comes with two built-in tools that come in handy plenty of times: a sharpener and a smudging tool.

Scroll to Top